Working capital loan vs revenue-based financing: which fits a services business
5 min read
The quick answer
As of 9 November 2026, repayment is the split, not price. A working capital loan or line is credit with a set principal and duration. Revenue-based financing is what New York law calls sales-based financing: you repay a share of revenue, so the payment moves with volume. Both must show an annualized rate in New York and California. Compare that number.
Two structures, and a naming trap
Start with the names, because they collide. Capital Selector's working capital page is the revenue-based one. It says plainly that "It is an advance, not a loan," priced at "a factor rate (for example 1.25), not an annual percentage rate," and that "You repay by remitting a set percentage of daily or weekly sales, or a fixed daily or weekly amount by ACH." The term loan page describes the other shape: "A term loan is a fixed amount of capital repaid over a set period with a fixed or variable rate," and "Because the payment schedule is fixed, a term loan is easy to plan around." A line of credit sits between them: you draw what you need and "pay interest only on the amount you draw."
So "working capital" on a term sheet can mean either structure. Ask which one you are being offered first.
What the law makes each side tell you
New York's commercial financing disclosure article splits the two the same way and then writes a separate disclosure rule for each. NY Financial Services Law § 801(j), "Definitions," turns on repayment as a percentage of sales or revenue, and adds that a fixed payment with a true-up to a percentage of revenue counts too, which catches most deals marketed as revenue-based.
| What you are comparing | What the statute says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| What a working capital loan is in statute | "Closed-end financing" includes financing with "an established principal amount and duration" | NY FSL § 801(d) |
| What revenue-based financing is in statute | A transaction "repaid by the recipient to the provider, over time, as a percentage of sales or revenue, in which the payment amount may increase or decrease according to the volume of sales made or revenue received by the recipient" | NY FSL § 801(j) |
| The rate a loan offer must show | "The annual percentage rate ... inclusive of any fees and finance charges that cannot be avoided by a recipient," calculated under Regulation Z, 12 C.F.R. § 1026.22 | NY FSL § 804(c) |
| The rate a revenue-based offer must show | "The estimated annual percentage rate," calculated under the same regulation but from a projected sales volume set by either the historical method or the opt-in method | NY FSL § 803(c) |
| The term on a loan | "The term of the financing" | NY FSL § 804(e) |
| The term on revenue-based financing | "The estimated term is the period of time required for the periodic payments, based on the projected sales volume, to equal the total amount required to be repaid" | NY FSL § 803(e) |
| What paying off early must disclose | Whether you would owe finance charges beyond interest accrued since the last payment, and the maximum dollar amount, with § 804(h) imposing the same on a closed-end loan | NY FSL § 803(h) |
| What California requires, on either | Six items, including "The total cost of the financing expressed as an annualized rate," signed by the recipient before the transaction is consummated | Cal. Fin. Code § 22802(a), (b) |
| Where the California rule stops | A "recipient" is a person presented an offer "equal to or less than five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000)" | Cal. Fin. Code § 22800(n) |
| Where the New York rule stops | The article does not apply to "an individual commercial financing transaction in an amount over two million five hundred thousand dollars" | NY FSL § 802(g) |
Three readings follow. The revenue-based number is an estimate built on a sales projection, and § 803(c) lets the provider pick between an average of recent months and a forward projection it elects, so ask which method produced the figure. The annualized figure is a disclosure, not how an advance is priced: the price is still the factor rate, which is why both numbers can sit on the same page. And both laws exempt banks, at Cal. Fin. Code § 22801(a) and NY FSL § 802(a), so a bank quote may arrive in a different format.
Why a services business reads this differently
A services firm bills on terms rather than at a card reader. Revenue lands in lumps when invoices clear, and a daily or weekly remittance takes its share on the provider's calendar instead of yours. Capital Selector's own disclosure on that page puts it directly: "Frequent remittance can affect cash flow." The same page says that "If your profile supports a term loan or line of credit, those are almost always cheaper."
SBA's working capital programs are built around that pattern. Under "7(a) Working Capital Pilot (WCP) program," SBA's 7(a) page lists, under "Who can benefit?", a business that "Operates in industries like manufacturing, wholesale, or professional services," has "at least one-year of operating history," and can produce "timely and accurate financial statements, accounts receivable and accounts payable agings, and inventory reports." Under "What are the terms?" that line runs to $5,000,000 with a maximum maturity of 60 months. On SBA's lender page, the "CAPLines" section calls the Working CAPline "an asset-based revolving line of credit for businesses unable to meet credit standards associated with long-term credit" and says it "generally is used by businesses that provide credit to other businesses." That is an invoicing services firm.
If the number in your head runs to a few million rather than a few hundred thousand, that is a different conversation, and the home page says where it goes: companies that have "outgrown advances and short-term lines" are introduced to a specialist firm in the Frontier Desk network, and only after you agree.
Two related guides cover the rest: line of credit vs merchant cash advance, and equipment financing, lease or loan.
Capital Selector is a financing marketplace, not a lender, and does not make credit decisions. Being matched is not an approval. As the disclosures say, "Approval, amounts, rates, and terms are determined solely by the lender after its own review." This guide is general information, not financial, tax or legal advice.
Questions
Is revenue-based financing the same as a merchant cash advance? In New York's statutory language, both sit inside sales-based financing under § 801(j), which turns on repayment as a percentage of sales or revenue. Market labels vary, so read the repayment mechanic rather than the name.
Can I compare an advance to a loan on rate alone? Compare the annualized figures, which is what these laws exist to make possible, but read the term with it: under § 803(e) the revenue-based term is an estimate that moves with your sales, while under § 804(e) the loan term is fixed. The calculators show what each payment looks like.
What if my state has no disclosure law? Ask for the same six items California lists in § 22802(b) anyway: funds provided, total dollar cost, term, payment method and amount, prepayment policy, and the annualized rate. A provider that will not put those in writing has told you something.
Does comparing options affect my credit? No. The readiness tool runs with "No sign-up, no credit pull." A soft check may run when you ask to see real offers, and a soft check does not affect your score.
Sources
- NY Financial Services Law § 801, Definitions
- NY Financial Services Law § 802, Exemptions
- NY Financial Services Law § 803, Sales-based financing disclosure requirements
- NY Financial Services Law § 804, Closed-end commercial financing disclosure requirements
- Cal. Fin. Code § 22800, Commercial Financing Disclosures definitions
- Cal. Fin. Code § 22801, exemptions
- Cal. Fin. Code § 22802, disclosure requirements
- SBA 7(a) loans
- SBA lenders, program comparison and CAPLines
- Capital Selector working capital and advance
- Capital Selector term loan
- Capital Selector line of credit
- Capital Selector calculators
- Capital Selector readiness
- Capital Selector disclosures
- Capital Selector guide, line of credit vs merchant cash advance
- Capital Selector guide, equipment financing lease or loan
See what your business qualifies for.
A short conversation is all it takes to get matched across a 75+ lender network.
Get matched